Can I conclude that given calvintaneng's very very high intrinsic values for these 10 stocks, might he be in one of his high mood swings phase? Will need his friends or family members to look out for this, in case.

Another question raised is, "Why is such a smart person like calvintaneng who floods this forum with repeated words of wisdom, quoting from Buffett to Peter Lynch, got his 10 stocks so wrong in August 2017? I hope you agree his 10 stocks selection in August 2017 were just terrible, using whatever comparison measures.

Might calvintaneng be a better investor if he had taken time to study his own mistakes, before continuing to show to others his prowess and cleverness.

What lessons might calvintaneng gained from these 10 stocks of his? Since he did give the intrinsic values for each of these stocks, might we assume he did do some work on deriving these. If he did, he could have reworked his valuation and learned where he might have made his mistakes. His intrinsic values by any measures were just far too high. Was calvintaneng prone to mania or depression? Perhaps, in this hypomanic phase, calvintaneng could see no risk and just rewards, huge ones as so.?

An obvious question raised by calvintaneng's post in this thread is, "Why were his intrinsic values for these companies in August 2017 were so much higher than their share prices in August 2017?

Wasn't calvintaneng a clever chap, since he was able to identify so many undervalued stocks in August 2017? These were not just undervalued, they were severely undervalued; just look at calvintaneng's intrinsic values for these stocks.

Do you believe in the efficient market hypothesis? I do. But I don't agree that the stock market is efficient ALL the time. That's why the hard working investor can diligently sometimes find an undervalued good/great company to invest into.

But, calvintaneng was able to identify 10 deeply undervalued stocks. How did he come about his valuation of these stocks?

Did he apply conservative assumptions in his valuation of their intrinsic values? Perhaps he did, or perhaps he did not.

Did he make mistakes in their valuation? If yes, these were MANY mistakes, not just the occasional ones. Should we be cautious in his promotions? Perhaps, we should not be cautious over this calvintaneng's promotions despite so many obvious mistakes?

Perhaps, calvintaneng wished to blame these 10 stocks on bad luck. It was just bad luck on that period. In other times, he had been in better luck. Should calvintaneng blamed these high intrinsic values not being achieved by his 10 stocks to bad luck? Or perhaps, he should not.

In August 2017, these 10 companies were trading at the following prices (in sen):
WTK 82
BJ Corp 32
MRCB 119
Bonia 55.5
Media Prima 75
CBIP 198
MUI 16.5
PBA 126
OPCOM 57.5
EIG 90


By calvintaneng's intrinsic value for these stocks in August 2017, the upside potentials for price appreciation of these stocks were as listed.

Potential Upside
WTK 252%
BJ Corp 1463%
MRCB 320%
Bonia 170%
Media Prima 167%
CBIP 203%
MUI 809%
PBA 138%
OPCOM 161%
EIG 233%


The potential upsides for these 10 stocks according to calvintaneng were a low of 138% (PBA) to a high of 1463% (BJCorp).

But alas, after 5.5 years of calvintaneng's listing of his 10 severe bargains, these are their returns today, should you have bought these stocks like calvintaneng in August 2017.

From 21.8.2017 to 4.1.2023
(slightly more than 5.5 years)

Gain/Loss
WTK -41%
BJ Corp -6%
MRCB -76%
Bonia 311%
Media Prima -43%
CBIP -44%
MUI -55%
PBA -40%
OPCOM 27%
EIG -66%

or

Over the last 5.5 years, here are the returns of the 10 stocks of calvintaneng

The obvious 1 big winner is BONIA (+311%).

There are 7 big losers. They lost from -40% to -76%.

OPCOM gains 27% while BJCorp lost -6%.

Why was the hero of Netx, calvintaneng so exuberant on these 10 stocks?
The answer is because by his analysis, all these 10 stocks trade at a big discount to their intrinsic value.

On August 2017, calvintaneng provided his intrinsic values for his 10 stocks.

INTRINSIC VALUE
WTK 289
BJ Corp 500
MRCB 500
Bonia 150
Media Prima 200
CBIP 600
MUI 150
PBA 300
OPCOM 150
EIG 300

>>>>

Posted by 3iii > 2017-08-22 17:27 | Report Abuse

The thrill of investing in stocks, using Peter Lynch's classification of companies.


1. Dutch Lady

A fast grower in its early days. Now a stalwart.


2. Nestle

A stalwart and slow grower. Generating high FCF with little capex requirement.

3. Aeon Credit.

A fast grower. Financial stock. High risk sector.

4. Guinness

A stalwart or slow grower.

5. Petdag

A fast grower over the last decade. Smaller company then, adding 50+ new petrol stations per year. Now a slow grower or stalwart.

6. HaiO

A gruesome stock that turned around in 2005 / 2006. Those who spotted this then would have a lot of gains when others started to show interest in it. Presently, a slow grower stock. Not to be dismissed.

7. KAF

For years, this stock lingered at price below its net asset value. In its book was a piece of land in Jalan Kia Peng which was worth a lot more. This land was subsequently repriced and the company eventually taken over by the majority shareholders. This was an asset play stock.

8. Topglove and Hartalega

These companies were fast growers. They are also in a cyclical sector. Essentially, they are cyclical growth stocks. Those who have own these stocks over the long term would have multibagger gains.

9. Tongher

A cyclical stock. Not easy to play in this sector. Presently, it is in its cyclical high.

10. Public Bank

A stalwart or slow grower.

11. Guan Chong

A turnaround and fast grower (but only for a year or so). Cyclical sector. Not easy to play these stocks but for those who spotted it in 2009, it did climbed 200% or so. However, to protect your gains, you need to sell and not hold long term. Not easy to play cyclical stocks. You need to buy right and also to sell right.

12. Pentamaster

A fast grower for the moment. A fast growth stock maybe highly priced. Be careful, but if you have spotted this before its price climbed, the rewards have been and can be huge.

13. GENM

Slow grower.

14. LPI

Slow grower that has delivered superior returns.

15. Scientex

Slow grower

>>>>>

How amusing and ironic to see this post of the hero of NETX, calvintaneng

>>>
Posted by calvintaneng > 2017-08-22 14:02 | Report Abuse

Peter Lynch categorize stocks into 6 Classes



1)Stalwarts

2)Fast Growers

3)Cyclicals

4)Turnarounds

5)Assets Play

6) Slow Growers


Calvin likes No. 1 to 5

3iii can only invest in no. 1 only.

See

1) The Eagle up in the Air Soar Above the Clouds and can SEE FROM SHORE TO SHORE

2) Other Flying Birds Can See From Mountain To Mountain or Tree to Tree\

3) The Chicken on the ground see nothing except to scratch for some earth worms

SO THE CHICKEN WITH MYOPIC EYESIGHT TELLS EAGLE HOW TO SEE?

LOL!!!
>>>>

For someone who claims to be a master of Peter Lynch's teachings, does calvintaneng exhibits that he understands Peter Lynch's teaching well.

Yet, calvintaneng thinks someone does not know Peter Lynch's teaching well. Yet, remarkably, the same chap bought BONIA at 80 sen in 2019 on his own analysis.

Just compare and contrast.

TOP 10 OVERSOLD STOCKS TO BUY NOW WHILE STILL VERY CHEAP! (Calvin Tan Research)
August 2017

This was the headline of the post by calvintaneng. Truly a disappointing result by any comparison. This raises many questions on calvintaneng's approach.

He became famous in his "totally blinded" promotion of NETX. The hero of Netx fame.

Over the last 5.5 years, here are the returns of the 10 stocks of calvintaneng

The obvious 1 big winner is BONIA (+311%).

There are 7 big losers. They lost from -40% to -76%.

OPCOM gains 27% while BJCorp lost -6%.

From 21.8.2017 to 4.1.2023
(slightly more than 5.5 years)

Gain/Loss
WTK -41%
BJ Corp -6%
MRCB -76%
Bonia 311%
Media Prima -43%
CBIP -44%
MUI -55%
PBA -40%
OPCOM 27%
EIG -66%

Their prices on 21.8.2017
While all love chasing Hot Air Balloon Stocks Calvin think these 10 Top Oversold Stocks are worth buying:

1) WTK (82 sen) Intrinsic Value Rm2.80. Target Price Rm1.60
2) BJ CORP (32 Sen) Intrinsic Value Rm5.00. Target Price Rm2.50
3) MRCB (Rm1.19) Intrinsic Value Rm5.00. Target price: Rm2.80
4) BONIA (55.5 sen) Intrinsic Value Rm1.50. Target Price : Rm1.20
5) MEDIA PRIMA (75 Sen) Intrinsic Value Rm2.00. Target Price: Rm1.50
6) CBIP (Rm1.98) Intrinsic Value Rm6.00. Target Price: Rm4.00
7) MUI BHD (16.5 sen) Intrinsic Value Rm1.50. Taget Price is 80 Sen
8) PBA (Rm1.26) Intrinsic Value Rm3.00. Target Price: Rm2.00
9) OPCOM (57.5 Sen) Intrinsic Value Rm1.50. Target Price: Rm1.20
10) EIG (Esthetic International) (90 Sen) Intrinsic Value Rm3.00. Target Price Rm2.00

And their prices on 4.1.2023 are:
WTK 48 sen
BCorp 30 sen
MRCB 29 sen
Bonia RM 2.28
Media Prima 43 sen
CBIP RM 1.11
MUI 7.5 sen
PBA 76 sen
OPCOM 73 sen
EIG 31 sen

The reasons given for the hero of Netx, calvintaneng's recommendatiions.

While all love chasing Hot Air Balloon Stocks Calvin think these 10 Top Oversold Stocks are worth buying:

1) WTK (82 sen) Intrinsic Value Rm2.80. Target Price Rm1.60
CPO prices now moving up
a) Canada Softwood impacted by drought & fire. b)Tokyo Olympic 2020 will spur logs/plywood sale.
2) BJ CORP (32 Sen) Intrinsic Value Rm5.00. Target Price Rm2.50
Something is brewing again. So time to load up.
3) MRCB (Rm1.19) Intrinsic Value Rm5.00. Target price: Rm2.80
ECER's Rm55 Billions Job, High Speed Rail, Bandar Malaysia, sale of EDL Highway to EPF or other Surprises?
4) BONIA (55.5 sen) Intrinsic Value Rm1.50. Target Price : Rm1.20
Bonia stand to do well in JPO sales to China Tourists. This one stock has fallen to bargain level
5) MEDIA PRIMA (75 Sen) Intrinsic Value Rm2.00. Target Price: Rm1.50
Morgan Stanley is buying and buying & its rich Cash Hoard will continue to give good dividends.
6) CBIP (Rm1.98) Intrinsic Value Rm6.00. Target Price: Rm4.00
INSIDERS once again started buying.
7) MUI BHD (16.5 sen) Intrinsic Value Rm1.50. Taget Price is 80 Sen
Divorce settlement will unlock Assets Sale. Just take position while cheap!
8) PBA (Rm1.26) Intrinsic Value Rm3.00. Target Price: Rm2.00
And PBA with its increased water tariff in Penang will see better earnings. Thus higher dividends could be expected
9) OPCOM (57.5 Sen) Intrinsic Value Rm1.50. Target Price: Rm1.20
FOR A NICE POSSIBLE "SPECIAL DIVIDEND OF AT LEAST 20 SEN?"
10) EIG (Esthetic International) (90 Sen) Intrinsic Value Rm3.00. Target Price Rm2.00
Only a tiny weeny 5.1% Shares left in Free Float in the Open Market.

5.5 years later, timely to review these 10 stocks recommendation of the hero of Netx, calvintaneng

From 21.8.2017 to 4.1.2023
(slightly more than 5.5 years)

Company Gain/Loss
WTK -41%
BJ Corp -6%
MRCB -76%
Bonia 311%
Media Prima -43%
CBIP -44%
MUI -55%
PBA -40%
OPCOM 27%
EIG -66%

Reference:
https://klse.i3investor.com/web/blog/detail/www.eaglevisioninvest.com/130378
THE INVESTMENT APPROACH OF CALVIN TAN
TOP 10 OVERSOLD STOCKS TO BUY NOW WHILE STILL VERY CHEAP! (Calvin Tan Research)

From 21.8.2017 to 4.1.2023 (slightly more than 5.5 years)

Company Gain/Loss
WTK -41%
BJ Corp -6%
MRCB -76%
Bonia 311%
Media Prima -43%
CBIP -44%
MUI -55%
PBA -40%
OPCOM 27%
EIG -66%

Company
Price (sen) 21.8.2017 4.1.2023 G/L
WTK 82 48 -41%
BJ Corp 32 30 -6%
MRCB 119 29 -76%
Bonia 55.5 228 311%
Media Prima 75 43 -43%
CBIP 198 111 -44%
MUI 16.5 7.5 -55%
PBA 126 76 -40%
OPCOM 57.5 73 27%
EIG 90 31 -66%

Reference:
https://klse.i3investor.com/web/blog/detail/www.eaglevisioninvest.com/130378
THE INVESTMENT APPROACH OF CALVIN TAN
TOP 10 OVERSOLD STOCKS TO BUY NOW WHILE STILL VERY CHEAP! (Calvin Tan Research)

Are we also surprised and amazed by the hero of NETX, calvintaneng's ebullience and broadcasting his fantastic fortune on BONIA and OPCOM, and cunningly silent on the other stocks. That is the hero of NETX in this forum.

Perhaps, he will write a follow up article on his 10 stocks pick. It is also honest to admit his mistakes (if he think this to be so). In my book, I always thought the integrity of the hero of NETX is doubtful.

Interestingly, I do own Bonia, one of the 10 stocks in the hero of NETX, calvintaneng's above list. It so happened that it is one of the two stocks that made a gain in his list. Yes, Bonia is the biggest winner in the above list. I must have done something not wrong. :-)

I bought Bonia in 2019 at 80 sen. It went up to 1.20 and I did not sell. Then it dropped to much much lower. Today it is much much higher. I have written on why I bought into Bonia in the Bonia thread a few weeks ago.

calvintaneng
Publish date: Mon, 21 Aug 2017, 02:49 AM
Dear Fellow Investors of i3 Forum,

While all love chasing Hot Air Balloon Stocks Calvin think these 10 Top Oversold Stocks are worth buying:

1) WTK (82 sen) Intrinsic Value Rm2.80. Target Price Rm1.60
2) BJ CORP (32 Sen) Intrinsic Value Rm5.00. Target Price Rm2.50
3) MRCB (Rm1.19) Intrinsic Value Rm5.00. Target price: Rm2.80
4) BONIA (55.5 sen) Intrinsic Value Rm1.50. Target Price : Rm1.20
5) MEDIA PRIMA (75 Sen) Intrinsic Value Rm2.00. Target Price: Rm1.50
6) CBIP (Rm1.98) Intrinsic Value Rm6.00. Target Price: Rm4.00
7) MUI BHD (16.5 sen) Intrinsic Value Rm1.50. Taget Price is 80 Sen
8) PBA (Rm1.26) Intrinsic Value Rm3.00. Target Price: Rm2.00
9) OPCOM (57.5 Sen) Intrinsic Value Rm1.50. Target Price: Rm1.20
10) EIG (Esthetic International) (90 Sen) Intrinsic Value Rm3.00. Target Price Rm2.00

And their prices today are:
WTK 48 sen
BCorp 30 sen
MRCB 29 sen
Bonia RM 2.28
Media Prima 43 sen
CBIP RM 1.11
MUI 7.5 sen
PBA 76 sen
OPCOM 73 sen
EIG 31 sen


Reference:
https://klse.i3investor.com/web/blog/detail/www.eaglevisioninvest.com/130378
THE INVESTMENT APPROACH OF CALVIN TAN
TOP 10 OVERSOLD STOCKS TO BUY NOW WHILE STILL VERY CHEAP! (Calvin Tan Research)

While all love chasing Hot Air Balloon Stocks Calvin think these 10 Top Oversold Stocks are worth buying:

1) WTK (82 sen) Intrinsic Value Rm2.80. Target Price Rm1.60
CPO prices now moving up
a) Canada Softwood impacted by drought & fire. b)Tokyo Olympic 2020 will spur logs/plywood sale.
2) BJ CORP (32 Sen) Intrinsic Value Rm5.00. Target Price Rm2.50
Something is brewing again. So time to load up.
3) MRCB (Rm1.19) Intrinsic Value Rm5.00. Target price: Rm2.80
ECER's Rm55 Billions Job, High Speed Rail, Bandar Malaysia, sale of EDL Highway to EPF or other Surprises?
4) BONIA (55.5 sen) Intrinsic Value Rm1.50. Target Price : Rm1.20
Bonia stand to do well in JPO sales to China Tourists. This one stock has fallen to bargain level
5) MEDIA PRIMA (75 Sen) Intrinsic Value Rm2.00. Target Price: Rm1.50
Morgan Stanley is buying and buying & its rich Cash Hoard will continue to give good dividends.
6) CBIP (Rm1.98) Intrinsic Value Rm6.00. Target Price: Rm4.00
INSIDERS once again started buying.
7) MUI BHD (16.5 sen) Intrinsic Value Rm1.50. Taget Price is 80 Sen
Divorce settlement will unlock Assets Sale. Just take position while cheap!
8) PBA (Rm1.26) Intrinsic Value Rm3.00. Target Price: Rm2.00
And PBA with its increased water tariff in Penang will see better earnings. Thus higher dividends could be expected
9) OPCOM (57.5 Sen) Intrinsic Value Rm1.50. Target Price: Rm1.20
FOR A NICE POSSIBLE "SPECIAL DIVIDEND OF AT LEAST 20 SEN?"
10) EIG (Esthetic International) (90 Sen) Intrinsic Value Rm3.00. Target Price Rm2.00
Only a tiny weeny 5.1% Shares left in Free Float in the Open Market.

And their prices today are:

WTK 48 sen
BCorp 30 sen
MRCB 29 sen
Bonia RM 2.28
Media Prima 43 sen
CBIP RM 1.11
MUI 7.5 sen
PBA 76 sen
OPCOM 73 sen
EIG 31 sen


Reference:
https://klse.i3investor.com/web/blog/detail/www.eaglevisioninvest.com/130378
THE INVESTMENT APPROACH OF CALVIN TAN
TOP 10 OVERSOLD STOCKS TO BUY NOW WHILE STILL VERY CHEAP! (Calvin Tan Research)

calvintaneng
Publish date: Mon, 21 Aug 2017, 02:49 AM
Dear Fellow Investors of i3 Forum,

calvintaneng
Publish date: Mon, 21 Aug 2017, 02:49 AM
Dear Fellow Investors of i3 Forum,

While all love chasing Hot Air Balloon Stocks Calvin think these 10 Top Oversold Stocks are worth buying:

1) WTK (82 sen) Intrinsic Value Rm2.80. Target Price Rm1.60
2) BJ CORP (32 Sen) Intrinsic Value Rm5.00. Target Price Rm2.50
3) MRCB (Rm1.19) Intrinsic Value Rm5.00. Target price: Rm2.80
4) BONIA (55.5 sen) Intrinsic Value Rm1.50. Target Price : Rm1.20
5) MEDIA PRIMA (75 Sen) Intrinsic Value Rm2.00. Target Price: Rm1.50
6) CBIP (Rm1.98) Intrinsic Value Rm6.00. Target Price: Rm4.00
7) MUI BHD (16.5 sen) Intrinsic Value Rm1.50. Taget Price is 80 Sen
8) PBA (Rm1.26) Intrinsic Value Rm3.00. Target Price: Rm2.00
9) OPCOM (57.5 Sen) Intrinsic Value Rm1.50. Target Price: Rm1.20
10) EIG (Esthetic International) (90 Sen) Intrinsic Value Rm3.00. Target Price Rm2.00

And their prices today are:
WTK 48 sen
BCorp 30 sen
MRCB 29 sen
Bonia RM 2.28
Media Prima 43 sen
CBIP RM 1.11
MUI 7.5 sen
PBA 76 sen
OPCOM 73 sen
EIG 31 sen


Reference:
https://klse.i3investor.com/web/blog/detail/www.eaglevisioninvest.com/130378
THE INVESTMENT APPROACH OF CALVIN TAN
TOP 10 OVERSOLD STOCKS TO BUY NOW WHILE STILL VERY CHEAP! (Calvin Tan Research)

While all love chasing Hot Air Balloon Stocks Calvin think these 10 Top Oversold Stocks are worth buying:

1) WTK (82 sen) Intrinsic Value Rm2.80. Target Price Rm1.60
CPO prices now moving up
a) Canada Softwood impacted by drought & fire. b)Tokyo Olympic 2020 will spur logs/plywood sale.
2) BJ CORP (32 Sen) Intrinsic Value Rm5.00. Target Price Rm2.50
Something is brewing again. So time to load up.
3) MRCB (Rm1.19) Intrinsic Value Rm5.00. Target price: Rm2.80
ECER's Rm55 Billions Job, High Speed Rail, Bandar Malaysia, sale of EDL Highway to EPF or other Surprises?
4) BONIA (55.5 sen) Intrinsic Value Rm1.50. Target Price : Rm1.20
Bonia stand to do well in JPO sales to China Tourists. This one stock has fallen to bargain level
5) MEDIA PRIMA (75 Sen) Intrinsic Value Rm2.00. Target Price: Rm1.50
Morgan Stanley is buying and buying & its rich Cash Hoard will continue to give good dividends.
6) CBIP (Rm1.98) Intrinsic Value Rm6.00. Target Price: Rm4.00
INSIDERS once again started buying.
7) MUI BHD (16.5 sen) Intrinsic Value Rm1.50. Taget Price is 80 Sen
Divorce settlement will unlock Assets Sale. Just take position while cheap!
8) PBA (Rm1.26) Intrinsic Value Rm3.00. Target Price: Rm2.00
And PBA with its increased water tariff in Penang will see better earnings. Thus higher dividends could be expected
9) OPCOM (57.5 Sen) Intrinsic Value Rm1.50. Target Price: Rm1.20
FOR A NICE POSSIBLE "SPECIAL DIVIDEND OF AT LEAST 20 SEN?"
10) EIG (Esthetic International) (90 Sen) Intrinsic Value Rm3.00. Target Price Rm2.00
Only a tiny weeny 5.1% Shares left in Free Float in the Open Market.

And their prices today are:

WTK 48 sen
BCorp 30 sen
MRCB 29 sen
Bonia RM 2.28
Media Prima 43 sen
CBIP RM 1.11
MUI 7.5 sen
PBA 76 sen
OPCOM 73 sen
EIG 31 sen


Reference:
https://klse.i3investor.com/web/blog/detail/www.eaglevisioninvest.com/130378
THE INVESTMENT APPROACH OF CALVIN TAN
TOP 10 OVERSOLD STOCKS TO BUY NOW WHILE STILL VERY CHEAP! (Calvin Tan Research)

calvintaneng
Publish date: Mon, 21 Aug 2017, 02:49 AM
Dear Fellow Investors of i3 Forum,

https://klse.i3investor.com/web/blog/detail/www.eaglevisioninvest.com/130378
THE INVESTMENT APPROACH OF CALVIN TAN
TOP 10 OVERSOLD STOCKS TO BUY NOW WHILE STILL VERY CHEAP! (Calvin Tan Research)

calvintaneng
Publish date: Mon, 21 Aug 2017, 02:49 AM
Dear Fellow Investors of i3 Forum,


Hero of NETX, calvintaneng

I recommend that you write a follow up article on the above post. Chun chun tank.
Your above recommendations should seriously send you to reexamine your stock selection ability. Are you honest to your goodself? That is very important indeed.

https://klse.i3investor.com/web/blog/detail/www.eaglevisioninvest.com/130378
THE INVESTMENT APPROACH OF CALVIN TAN
TOP 10 OVERSOLD STOCKS TO BUY NOW WHILE STILL VERY CHEAP! (Calvin Tan Research)

calvintaneng
Publish date: Mon, 21 Aug 2017, 02:49 AM
Dear Fellow Investors of i3 Forum,


Hero of NETX, calvintaneng

I recommend that you write a follow up article on the above post. Chun chun tank.
Your above recommendations should seriously send you to reexamine your stock selection ability. Are you honest to your goodself? That is very important indeed.

calvintaneng
Publish date: Mon, 21 Aug 2017, 02:49 AM
BONIA (55.5 sen) Intrinsic Value Rm1.50. Target Price : Rm1.20
https://klse.i3investor.com/web/blog/detail/www.eaglevisioninvest.com/130378

While price has fallen to all time low INSIDERS IS BUYING & BUYING. After Padini - Bonia stand to do well in JPO sales to China Tourists. This one stock has fallen to bargain level


Posted by calvintaneng 4/1/2022
Bonia was 48 sen now up over Rm2. 00 as well


Did you profit from the hero of NETX call on BONIA? He already posted on BONIA for years. One day, it looks so nice to post its lowest price and going up many folds. :-)

I own Bonia too. I bought this based on my own analysis

THE INVESTMENT APPROACH OF CALVIN TAN
HOW TO ESCAPE A FINANCIAL TSUNAMI by Calvin Tan

calvintaneng
Publish date: Tue, 08 Aug 2017, 01:47 PM

https://klse.i3investor.com/web/blog/detail/www.eaglevisioninvest.com/129506

WHY CALVIN TAN DOES NOT BUY GREATEC OR NEW IPO STOCKS (SEE PAST/PRESENT/FUTURE WEALTH ARTICLE REPOSTED

calvintaneng
Publish date: Wed, 26 Jun 2019, 10:43 PM

https://klse.i3investor.com/web/blog/detail/www.eaglevisioninvest.com/212495

June 2019 0.41 per share
Market Summary
>
Greatech Technology Bhd
4.69 MYR
+4.28 (1,043.90%) past 5 years
4 Jan, 5:00 pm MYT

https://klse.i3investor.com/web/blog/detail/Sslee_blog/2021-02-25-story-h1541261311-What_i3_stand_for_Is_Calvintaneng_your_friend_or_foe

Article written by SSLee, praising calvintaneng. Not so kind words for others with "tunnel visions". :-)

>>>>
3) RULE NO. THREE

HE THAT IS LOW NEEDS FEAR NO FALL.

BJ CORP MEETS THIS THIRD RULE PERFECTLY AS ITS PRICE IS NOW TRADING AT 3 YEAR LOW. AND COMPANY SHARE BUY BACK WAS TRIGGERED AT 48 CENTS RECENTLY.

Please do your own due diligence. Buy/sell at your own discretion/

LATEST UPDATE ON MARCH 30 2021

PLEASE BE CAREFUL OF PUNTING SHORT TERM
>>>>

BJCorp was at its highest price of 45 sen per share (1.4.2021) when calvintan posted on 30.3.2021. Since then, it has declined to 30 sen per share.

THE INVESTMENT APPROACH OF CALVIN TAN
BERJAYA CORPORATION - THE BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY OF MALAYSIA Author: calvintaneng | Publish date: Fri, 12 Feb 2016, 10:07 AM

calvintaneng
Publish date: Tue, 30 Mar 2021, 05:11 PM

https://klse.i3investor.com/web/blog/detail/www.eaglevisioninvest.com/2021-03-30-story-h1543072730-BERJAYA_CORPORATION_THE_BERKSHIRE_HATHAWAY_OF_MALAYSIA_Author_calvintan

POS (4634) - JACKMA JV WITH POS MALAYSIA WLL LIFT UP POS INTO A BLUE CHIP & DRB TO RM5.00 (Calvin Tan)

Dear Fellow Investors in i3 Forum,

I am so happy & elated today. 2 Top News emanation from Pm Najib's latest visit to China will benefit these 2 stocks the most
ht tps:/ /ww w.sharetisfy.c om /2016/11/pos-4634-jackma-jv-with-pos-malaysia. ht ml

https://klse.i3investor.com/web/blog/detail/www.eaglevisioninvest.com/2019-09-09-story-h1479209511-CRUDE_OIL_RISING_CAUSED_OGSE_BULL_RUN_NOW_BALTIC_DRY_INDEX_BDI_SURGE_WI

https://klse.i3investor.com/web/blog/detail/www.eaglevisioninvest.com/2019-09-05-story223488-MAYBULK_5077_FOLLOWS_BALTIC_DRY_INDEX_POWERFUL_UPTREND_FROM_500_PTS_TO_2518_PTS_Calvin_Tan_Research

https://klse.i3investor.com/web/blog/detail/www.eaglevisioninvest.com/2019-09-11-story-h1479234400-MAYBULK_5077_HUGE_CHANGE_OF_FORTUNE_EXPLAINED_STEP_BY_STEP_CLEARLY_Calv

calvintaneng

They have not sold any

That means that they have faith in the company

Unlike transmile, Megan media and seacera directors sold all Directors of Maybulk believe the Company prospects

2019-09-12 00:26


3iii

Why did they not sell? Well, you need to fathom behavioural finance to understand more.

OTOH keep focus on the insiders.

I made a lot of money on Maybulk before it went down. Sold the majority of my shares before its decline few years back. My last few shares were sold off at 2.20 each.

When a company's fundamentals deteriorated, SELL.

In earlier years, Maybulk was a very good company to own. Its core business was profitable. However, the company made a lot of money when it sold its hard assets (carriers) for huge profits due to shortage of capacity in the industry. These extraordinary income boosted its cash and Maybulk rewarded its shareholders with generous dividends. Accordingly, its share price too increased.

All its directors owned substantial shares in their own names prior to 2008. Post 2008, this sector went into a decline. World trade diminished. Too many new carriers were built during the good time. There were too much capacity. BDI dropped. By the time its earnings were decimated, all its directors had sold all their shares. Yes, do keep an eye on the insiders' activities regarding their buying and selling.

Maybulk is a hard asset company. It is capital intensive with high fixed costs and high capex. There are better companies to hold long term.

2019-09-12 07:44

>>>>

>>>>
Stock: [NETX]: NETX HOLDINGS BHD

2019-12-01 08:05 | Report Abuse

add on to A witness for my disastrous stock: muiind promoted by calvintaneng
30/11/2019 11:34 PM
i hated calvintaneng, if it was not him talking so sure about selling assets the only way for court settlement, i wouldnt have bought muiind, the wording and the analysis he used were all meant for the only way was to dispose assets of muiind.
Anyhow, slowly i put down hates, now really no more hate to calvintaneng, because i know more about investing and about sharing in this i3 forum, now i know it's my fault too.
Just, really reading comments from calvintaneng in here reminds me things that happened when muiind kept going down, telling this story just to remind you all here calvintaneng has the selling points but u bear the responsibility, the selling points are not 100% happen even the wording and analysis are meant for 100%, like what happened in muiind.

Stock
Stock: [NETX]: NETX HOLDINGS BHD

2019-11-30 23:34 | Report Abuse

A witness for my disastrous stock: muiind promoted by calvintaneng

it's about 2years ago, i was new in share trading, i read articles by calvin promoting muiind. At that time he's so sure that the losing divorce case of kkp will force him release value of muiind for court settlement for his plaintiff ex-wife. calvin promoted so much even when share price up so much at around 25-28c, i bought in at 26.5c, even price went down to 20c and below, he kept insisting price would go up 2x, 3x, 4x, or even more than 10 times when assets being sold.
eventually price kept going down till 16c, nothing happened. i lost a lot of money.
Now, i saw the comments here and calvin insisting on price would be going sky rocketed, reminding me the same thing like muiind that really haunts me until now.

https://klse.i3investor.com/web/cube/profile/newbie2014

>>>>>

In 2025, the shareholders will have to decide to continue with iCAP as it is or to liquidate it. I believe, after 20 years of managing this fund, ttb will allow the shareholders to decide. Of course, these two choices have their proponents. Nearer the date, each group will galvanise to win their respective proposal.

Of course, the CL would like to restructure this fund, hoping to cash out at full or close to full value to NAV. How will ttb respond be? He has managed this fund for 20 years by 2025. By this time, he will be close to 70 years old. Will he be as focused on this fund, now that he seems to be very busy increasing his asset under management, the single factor which determines ensured high profitability for any fund managers. For the many who have supported ttb all this time, by 2025, many would have grown 20 years older too. Will they continue to support the extension of iCAP in its present form?

Many of the close-end funds in Malaysia and Singapore were liquidated for many reasons. For many, the returns were not fantastic. Also many traded at huge discount to their NAV. It was overall, frustrating for both the investors and the managers. Disgrunted investors with demotivated managers led to their liquidation, keeping the disgrunted investors happy. Of course, the funds specialising in severely discounted close end funds and catalysing their liquidation walk away with their big returns too.

I did show him how I valued this stock. :-)
Surprisingly the analyst from the investing brokers actually gave lower intrinsic value to TSH; thus I was a bit over-generous. However, I ask for a high margin of safety to protect against imprecision, bad luck or error in my analysis.

>>>
Posted by calvintaneng > 31 minutes ago | Report Abuse

Hahaha

Teach intrinsic value to dinosaur ?

Might as well teach a crab how to walk straight and stop walking sideways

The crab can never understand lah
>>>>


As I expected, rather than taking the bull by the horn and shines, he chooses his usual responses. Thanks for confirming what I already know about the hero of NETX, calvintan.
Just study his promotion in NETX and this is no different from all his other promotions. Hero of NETX, calvintan will tell you he that the price will go up. :-) Investing is so easy, like so. :-) :-)

Window dressing—the practice of making a portfolio look good for quarterly reporting purposes

Value - the worth, calculated through fundamental analysis, of an asset, business, or security

Value investing—a risk-averse investment approach designed to buy securities at a discount from underlying value

Value investment—undervalued security; a bargain

Treasury bills (T-bills)—noninterest-bearing obligations of the U.S. government, issued on a discount basis with original maturities ranging from three months to one year; the interest income from Treasury bills is the difference between the purchase price and par

Treasury notes (T-notes) —U.S. government obligations with original maturities ranging from one to ten years; interest is paid semiannually

Treasury bonds (T-bonds) —U.S. government obligations with original maturities of ten years or more; interest is paid semiannually

Trader—a person whose job it is to buy and sell securities, earning a spread or commission for bringing buyers and sellers together

Torpedo stocks—stocks for which investors have high expectations and which are therefore vulnerable to substantial price declines

Tender offer—a cash bid to buy some or all of the securities of a target company

Self-tender—an offer by a company to repurchase its own securities

Tax-loss selling—selling just prior to year-end to realize losses for tax purposes

Senior-debt security—security with the highest priority in the hierarchy of a company’s capital structure

Subordinated-debt security - security with a secondary priority in the hierarchy of a company’s capital structure

Sensitivity analysis—a method of ascertaining the sensitivity of business value to small changes in the assumptions made by investors

Security—a marketable piece of paper representing the fractional ownership of a business or loan to a business or government entity

Secured debt—debt backed by a security interest in specific assets

Return—potential gain

Risk—amount and probability of potential loss