News Felda Global Ventures (“FGV”) has proposed to undertake the offer to acquire all Pontian United Plantations (“Pontian”) shares for a total cash consideration of RM1.21b. This is based on the price of RM140 per share on 8.65m total Pontian shares.
We gather that the offer is conditional as it will be valid if FGV received more than 50% of Pontian’s shares. As of 18-July-2013, FGV has obtained irrevocable undertakings from multiple Pontian shareholders amounting to a 23.81% stake.
Note that Pontian owns 40,000 acres (16,188 ha) plantation, which is mostly in Sabah (Kinabatangan and Lahad Datu). In addition, Pontian owns a CPO processing mill with capacity of 90 mt/hour.
Comments We believe the valuation of the deal at RM74,794/ha is fair as it is comparable to valuation of RM75,000 –RM80,000 per ha for matured Sabah plantation estate. As the surrounding area has been developed into palm oil estate many years ago, we believe more than 95% of Pontian estates are matured with FFB yield comparable to other Sabah estates at 28 mt/ha.
We are positive on the deal as FY14E earnings may increase by 6% to RM950m if the deal materializes. Although the valuation of Pontian at 30.7x historical PE is higher than FGV’s 21.6x, the premium is justified as we believe Pontian’s FFB yield should be higher at 28 mt/ha (against FGV’s 20 mt/ha).
Outlook If the deal materialize, FGV’s efficiency should increase slightly due to expected overall increase in FFB yield/ha.
However, current low CPO prices are likely to keep FGV share price upside limited.
Forecast Pending the possible acceptance of more than 50% from Pontian shareholders, we maintain our FY13EFY14E core earnings of RM723m-RM895m.
Rating Maintain MARKET PERFORM
Valuation Maintain TP of RM4.60 based on unchanged 18.7x Fwd.
PE on CY14E EPS of 24.5 sen.
Risks Lower than expected CPO prices.
Source: Kenanga
ksszetho
If offer price of RM1.21bn at RM140/sh on 8.65m shares implies a historical PE of 30.7, then historical EPS was RM4.56/sh. Hence, PU's historical NP was RM39.446m p.a. This compares with potential interest income of RM38.72m p.a. at 3.2% p.a. if the RM1.21bn is placed in fixed deposits. Ceteris paribus, at RM39.446m NP p.a., the payback period for this investment is about 30 years. A damn good deal for the owners of Pontian United, especially when the estate and mill are pretty old (more than 15 years, I hazard a guess). Some 95% of the plantings must be in the prime or past-prime category, and quite similar to most of FGV's plantations, massive replanting is necessary in due course. With part of PU's property prone to flooding during monsoon, and the nagging problem of harvesters shortage, the assumption that PU's FFB yield/ha could be close to 28mt/ha is wishful thinking indeed.
2013-07-20 15:04