== Market Cap ==
Company IPO date IPO Now Change
Petronas Chem 26/11/2010 42,480 53,600 26%
Maxis 19/11/2009 40,650 44,836 10%
IHH 25/07/2012 24,891 54,855 120%
Felda 28/06/2012 19,335 5,363 -72%
Astro 19/10/2012 15,592 15,199 -3%
Bumi Armada 21/07/2011 12,124 4,165 -66%
Westports 18/10/2013 9,037 14,356 59%
Malakoff 15/05/2015 9,000 8,400 -7%
UMW O&G 01/11/2013 6,702 2,000 -70%
AirAsia X 10/07/2013 2,963 1,452 -51%
Some comments:
- 6 out of 10 companies are still below their IPO price, that is not impressive at all
- if one would put the same amount of money in each stock, then one would have a loss of 5%
- on average the companies IPO-ed about 3.5 years ago
- for international investors, the RM is down by about 20% versus the USD since 3.5 years ago, so the results are much worse
- the market cap off all 10 companies together has risen though, since their combined IPOs
- it is mostly IHH saving the day, with EPF continuing to buy IHH shares aggressively even at a rich PE of around 60
- Maxis, Astro, Bumi Armada and Malakoff are all "listed-delisted-relisted" cases, Bursa should really take decisive action to discourage this kind of financial engineering which comes at the expense of the minority shareholders, it is long overdue
- quite a few resource related companies on the list, they have not fared well lately
There was once a time when companies were listed at single digit PEs supported by profit guarantees, the valuation was set by the authorities. Needless to say, there was a lot of interest by investors, and some IPOs were oversubscribed by 100 times.
Those days are over, companies nowadays set their own price, which is of course correct. New, "sexy" terms were introduced by financial engineers, like "cornerstone investors", "greenshoe options" and "stabilising manager".
But from the above data, it seems the IPO price is often quite rich these days, and not much upside (if any) is provided in exchange for the risk that IPO investors take.
Combined with my previous posting about poor earnings growth for the Top 30 companies (not surprisingly there is quite some overlap), things don't look that impressive.
Bursa can hold as many international roadshows as they want, but at the end of the day, it is the fundamentals and valuations that count. And they really have to improve.
NK Goh
rich man game.
2016-04-20 18:00