The first thing one should ask is not how much cash a business has, but what the business is going to grow the cash pile it has. Because as a minority shareholder you have no access to that cash, but simply whatever forms of dividends or share buybacks that the company is willing to do.
In this case the correct question is to ask why is the company valued lower than the nett cash it has?
The simple answer I can find is simply that the company doesn't make much money at all, and the earnings it has right now is simply by selling the plantations that it has for more prices instead of growing more (a trick that the old tradewinds manager seems fond of doing before, selling).
In any case would you buy a company whose central business model 77% is in the lpg business, and yet from 456 million in revenue, only makes 11+ million in profit? That is a gross profit of 2.4%.
Their ict telecommunications business is losing money, they are selling off the plantations they do have in agro.
So since we will not be able to access that pile of cash at all, and I fully believe management will be using that money to finance new business models( which may or may not be successful), the simple fact is you cannot value the company simply based on the cash they have which is the past, but try to estimate the future cash flow it will have.
That would be the real possibility of looking at why the share price will go up and how you will really benefit.
@philip, I do not disagree with your comment. It is definitely interesting to see what development this company has in the future given that much cash in the company currently.
However, if you notice, there seems to be DBT transactions these past few days. Seems like a few big blocks crossing at 0.60 cents. If the costs to new owners is at 0.60, i think the price now would be very very attractive, unless i'm wrong.
This book is the result of the author's many years of experience and observation throughout his 26 years in the stockbroking industry. It was written for general public to learn to invest based on facts and not on fantasies or hearsay....
Philip ( buy what you understand)
4,903 posts
Posted by Philip ( buy what you understand) > 2021-09-30 08:08 | Report Abuse
The first thing one should ask is not how much cash a business has, but what the business is going to grow the cash pile it has. Because as a minority shareholder you have no access to that cash, but simply whatever forms of dividends or share buybacks that the company is willing to do.
In this case the correct question is to ask why is the company valued lower than the nett cash it has?
The simple answer I can find is simply that the company doesn't make much money at all, and the earnings it has right now is simply by selling the plantations that it has for more prices instead of growing more (a trick that the old tradewinds manager seems fond of doing before, selling).
In any case would you buy a company whose central business model 77% is in the lpg business, and yet from 456 million in revenue, only makes 11+ million in profit? That is a gross profit of 2.4%.
Their ict telecommunications business is losing money, they are selling off the plantations they do have in agro.
So since we will not be able to access that pile of cash at all, and I fully believe management will be using that money to finance new business models( which may or may not be successful), the simple fact is you cannot value the company simply based on the cash they have which is the past, but try to estimate the future cash flow it will have.
That would be the real possibility of looking at why the share price will go up and how you will really benefit.
My 2 cents.