The company’s 1H19 result was really disappointing for the investors with total profit of only RM2.7mil a fall of more than 75% vs 1H18 results even though revenue actually grew by 7%. The fall in profit margins is contributed by higher raw material (resin), labour, financing and depreciation costs (of which the last 2 are related to the new plant in Kulai). 3Q19 is expected to still deliver below par result due to the delay in the migration to the new plant which is only expected to be completed by end Jan (instead of the earlier target of Oct 18).
FY19 would most probably end by the company only reaching a profit of around RM8-10mil. FY20 would see a better result but given the intense competition for some of the company main products (like lunchboxes and cups) couple with the still high operating costs, investors should only expect a full year profit of around RM15mil in FY20. At the current share price, this would mean the company is already carrying a higher than average valuation of 16x PE.
Another potential problem that need to be monitor by investors is the liquidity issue currently faced by the company with current debt obligation of RM51mil and a cash reserve of only RM7.6mil. If management fails to convert the high trade receivables and inventories (RM47mil and RM38mil respectively) to cash fast enough, the company might need to depend on using more debt to refinance existing debt. Given the higher interest rate trend, this would most likely hit on the P&L of the company in the future.
If you are looking to diversify your portfolio outside of SCGM (due to its earnings uncertainties, relatively high valuation and potential liquidity issue) I would recommend you to look at MBMR.
MBMR is a direct proxy to Perodua via its 22.6% interest in the company. Valuation is cheap at only 6.9x PE (based on target FY18 profit of RM145mil. 9m profit is already RM106mil). PB is low at only 0.7x BV. 4Q18 results is expected to be higher than 3Q18 and last year's 4Q17.
FY19 growth will be driven by the still high demand of the new Myvi and the newly launched SUV Aruz and also the newly revamp Alza in 2H19. The recent announcement of closure and potential disposal of the loss-making alloy wheel manufacturing business alone is expected to boost the company’s profit by an additional RM20mil. I am projecting a profit to shareholder of RM170 mil for FY19 which at the current price values MBMR at only 5.9x PE.
Please go through the analyst reports (https://klse.i3investor.com/servlets/stk/pt/5983.jsp) and do your own analysis before making any decisions. There are 8 analysts in total covering the stock with most of them having a TP of above RM3 (all have a buy rating). The average TP for the 8 analysts is around RM3.50.
The main reason for loss making is high operating expenses resulted from new plant's start-up cost. SCGM managed to maintain its sales revenue due to persistent high demand for its products. It will take some times for its new plant to contribute and bring the profit to new height. The management claimed the new plant will be fully commissioned by end Apr'19. It is good to buy on dip if its stock price falls to ~RM1 tomorrow. It is a stock needs to keep for ~1 year to bear fruits.
1. The spot price of the resin dropped since December 2019, it being consistently hovering at a lower price and further dropped to 1 year low ... currently...
2. Plastic ban and biodegradable food wrapping/tray demand will be getting bigger and bigger due to the rise of the environment consciousness... How SCGM capture the market and outbeat their competitor, yet is still an unknown.
3. Cost passing mechanism of these product is NOT high... imagine if you sell 10c for a wrap, and by tomorrow you say , oh i'm sorry , it's 20c now because the cost of producing those stuff escalated... I bet most of their customer will switch to their competitor that has a more stable pricing mechanism...
4. Those whom worried about rising inventory/receivable and decreasing cash balance , i just want to inform you that this is the nature of "trading" business... they rely on credit to revolve. Look at other "trading" business and you will see such cashflow is quite a norm... example SAMCHEM or the previous ECS .
5. I haven't tracked this counter for a long time, but base on the track record and the management attitude (willing to distribute the profit and dividend), i think you can consider this company ... when it is on it's upleg cycle again.
Seeing silver lining in resin cost for SCGM. Resin cost, which accounted for 70% of total operating costs, has been on the gradual downtrend since oil prices corrected more than 22% after hitting USD84.80 in Oct 2018. PP, which accounts for 50% of total resin usage, is expected to face more competitive pricing from Petronas following the soon-to-be-completed Pengerang downstream project as Petronas’ resin capacity easily outweighs Lotte Chemical’s. PET, which made up about 40% of the Group’s total resin usage, will see a surge of supply from its main supplier, MPI Polyester Industries following the opening of a new production plant in Vietnam. We believe the Group would be able to ride on recent lower resin cost in 4QFY19 as it adopts a spot-pricing policy for resin orders, which is up to 1 month only.
Many forsaw no good QR for the 3rd Q but a good 4th Q... That's why there was no significant drop in the price after announcement of the loss making 3rd QR.
Two Market Sifu forecast a good 4th QR, Absolutelystock.com (Tong Kooi Ong) and Dynaquest (Dr Neoh Soon Kian).
I am from SCGM Representative. My name is David Cheng. Plastics will not be a sunset industry as the company has recently announced its partnership with PT Harapan Mulia to develop Oxium degradable products for the mass market both domestic and international. SCGM has developed several OXIUM related products during the Sea Games and has continued to do so until today.
As mentioned before, we have just recently completed and commissioned our new plant, in anticipation of new development for a full range of Oxium products as well as moving forward more environment-friendly products. Our recent net loss was attributed to several factors, mainly the finance cost. Most of you are aware that our old plant is not able to expand further due to limitations in size and supply of electricity. A big major expansion is necessary for anticipation for greater growth and bigger market share.
In reply to MK Zee Mun Keat, To answer your question, our strategic alliance with PT Harapan is a good move as local distributors would be able to understand the different cultural needs and wants of the local market. Most containers are developed under the "ECORASA", and since then it has gained traction. We are beginning to the fruit of our effort for the past year. We believe the market will bear even more fruit when we make further inroads to the market.
Hi Mr. Ng, for clarification SCGM do not produce biodegradable plastic. The terminology biodegradable must be from raw materials made of plant or organic base. However, SCGM produces photo and oxo degradable which is still plastic based but with degradable addictives such as OXIUM. We do not have any plans to sign up with franchise operator as the volume is not significant and retailers can purchase directly from our 30 plus distributors around Malaysia.
Hi Dave Cheng, Can you please explain and elaborate your "photo and oxo degradable which is still plastic", how long does it take for the plastic to be degraded and what is the true meaning of "degradable"? How well do the packaging materials used by SCGM go down with the Environment Authority? Are the materials considered "environment friendly"?
hi Dave Cheng, thanks for speaking to us here. If SCGM's products are oxo-degradable or photo-degradable, then the products likely won't degrade in the anaerobic conditions of our landfills (and Indonesia's, I presume). And EU is trying to ban oxo-degradable plastics because these might just break into microplastics and further harm the environment. Is SCGM going to address the limited potential (both environmental and economic) of these products? https://www.european-bioplastics.org/eu-takes-action-against-oxo-degradable-plastics/ http://ecostandard.org/wp-content/uploads/oxo-statement.pdf
please explain on impact of resin price on SCGM costs ? and what action will SCGM make to control and make sure SGCM still profitable in the view of unstable resin price (resin price up and down follow the oil price)?
It seems fullmikcream's highlight is frightening. You can solve the degradability issue on condition the used plastic is exposed to sunlight for 5 years. If the used plastic is buried, it can take as much as 50 years to breakdown into microplastic which is a lot more harmful.
The European Commission has recommended EU-wide measures be taken against so-called ‘oxo-degradable‘ plastics. In a report published earlier this month, the Commission said that “a process to restrict the use of oxo-plastics in the EU will be started”. European Bioplastics (EUBP), the association of the bioplastics industry in Europe, strongly welcomes this clear commitment to take action. “EUBP has long been warning about the harmful effects of oxo-degradable plastics on the environment as well as the potential damage to the reputation and understanding of truly biodegradable plastics. Several cases of greenwashing and false claims have been reported over the past years that have lead to confusion about biodegradation in the general public,” says Hasso von Pogrell, Managing Director of EUBP.
for your information, bioplastic is another degradable industry that uses corn plastic as their main source of plastic, European bioplastic is currently representing this organisation, currently in malaysia palm oil case, European countries is also trying to protect their own industry much like palm oil vs sunflower seed oil.... this is like american association research spam on butter for heart disease that after 50 years is not found to be true.
For all post related to degradable materials, please be informed that an informal session will be held in Kuala Lumpur. Time and date to be advised. Please be informed if you wish to know more about degradable additives used by SCGM, all of you are invited to attend the INFORMAL SESSION. Strictly NO FOOD served. Subsequent to the event, please be advised that you post factual information about the company.
This book is the result of the author's many years of experience and observation throughout his 26 years in the stockbroking industry. It was written for general public to learn to invest based on facts and not on fantasies or hearsay....
D_investor
2 posts
Posted by D_investor > 2019-01-12 08:52 | Report Abuse
https://mcoremart.com/index.php/product/scgm-berhad-key-points-report/