KUALA LUMPUR: Khazanah Research Institute (KRI) is challenging Malaysia's household classification, arguing that only the top 30 per cent of households are truly middle-income or aspirational.
KRI's findings contrast with the government's view that the top 60 per cent, made up of Middle 40 (M40) and Top 20 (T20) groups, are middle class.
Malaysia has consistently followed the World Bank's demarcation of Bottom 40 (B40)/M40/T20 from the Ninth Malaysia Plan (9MP) to the Eleventh Malaysia Plan (11MP) for almost 15 years from 2006-2020.
"Our findings challenge the existing B40, M40 and T20 classification that reveals discrepancies between income demarcations and actual expenditure patterns," it said in a report entitled "Searching for the 'Poor' and the 'Middle-Class' in Malaysia" released today.
KRI instead classifies households as Bottom 20 per cent (B20), Middle 50 per cent (M50) and Top 30 per cent (T30).
KRI said B20 households are focused on meeting basic needs such as food, housing and clothing; M50 are economically unstable households navigating trade-offs between essential and aspirational goods while T20 are households demonstrating aspirational consumption patterns indicative of the middle class, but not necessarily "wealthy" by global standards.
KRI said the M50 group still face trade-offs between basic needs and more aspirational products, with only small differences from the B20 group. Some can afford dining out, send children to tuition, or buy more furniture.
However, the M50 is not considered middle class and remains vulnerable.
The KRI report comes amid the Economy Ministry's efforts to define and classify the top 15 income group, which will see a reduction in government subsidies.
https://www.nst.com.my/business/economy/2024/12/1154750/khazanah-research-institute-challenges-governments-household
Created by savemalaysia | Dec 31, 2024
Created by savemalaysia | Dec 31, 2024
Created by savemalaysia | Dec 31, 2024
Created by savemalaysia | Dec 31, 2024
Define Top 10% as those who can afford to stay in big house and unlimited overseas travel where and when they like.
Define Lower Top 10% as those who can afford to stay in million ringgit condo or landed house. Can go overseas trip at least twice a year and unlimited local travel for the whole family.
Define Upper Middle (I) 10% as those who can afford to stay in million ringgit condo or landed house. Can go overseas trip at least once a year and several local travel for the whole family.
Define Upper Middle (II) 10% as those who can afford to stay in at least a double storey house or a standard condo unit. Occasionally overseas trip for husband and wife.
Define Mid Middle 10% as those who can afford to stay in a double storey house or at least a single storey house.
Define Lower Middle 10% as those who can afford to stay in a single sorey house or a PRR.
Up to you to figure out the rest of B40.
2 days ago
classify citizens based on income, or race, or gender or religion is discriminatory double standard, like apartheid no difference. Law should be fair and standard applicable to all regardless of all social class
2 days ago
ks55
Top 10%
Lower Top 10%
Upper Middle (I) 10%
Upper Middle (II) 10%
Mid Middle 10%
Lower Middle 10%
Upper Lower (I) 10%
Upper Lower (II) 10%
Mid Lower 10%
Poor 10%
Total 100%
Just need to assign a figure to each category to be better represented.
2 days ago