Read the article carefully. Remove DMO, up export levy. Remember what happen the last time export tax being implemented in Malaysia? Remember, world supply does not change. But Indo CPO become expensive.
@tehcping. just wonder what reit counter you buy causing you so much losses.? I bought UOA,, SENTRAL, and Atrium, all profited. Zhulian and Uoadev may not be reit, but dividend yield is much higher than reit, did you study before you purchase any share?
Why so -ve? DMO removed, yes, international supply increase, BUT TOTAL WORLD demand n supply is same. YET additional levy will make Malaysia CPO more attractive…
In the Starbiz, SOP’s cost of production for FY21 was $1,500 to $1,600 pmt CPO . For FY22, it is estimated to increase about 10 to 15% yoy. Bplant cost of production may be $200 higher due to lower average yield. Even if CPO is $5,000, Bplant will still make huge profits!
Largest influx of rookie was May-June 2020. My remiser normally sign up 5 people per month becomes 20 a week. End of 2020, everyone became godshen. And so, I tell these rookies that if you made money from glove, time to exit liao. Ofcos, they were making 50-100% and wouldn't sell. They accused me of jealous of their success.
A year later, they wiped 50-60% off their portfolio from glove alone. Even more from their desperation to cover their loses by trading. Guess what? They blame me from jinxing them. Woahhhh...
All rookies think that they have a trick or two up their sleeve to beat the market. The truth is they don't and only realizes that after their fingers turns into ashes. Not to say I wasn't one of them. But I survived and market taught me important lesson. Mummy will tell to listen. That's easy. What's not easy is to listen when things going well. When TG at RM24 that time, every rookies upgraded their forehead with vibranium and as thick 2ft wall.
Not easy to see the name around over the years. -------------------------------------------------------------- wallstreetrookie
A lot of beginners give investing advice here. We will see how well they perform after 3 months. My broker friend at M Plus Securities told me that most people lose their entire trading portfolio in 90 days. You wait and see
tell us something we do NOT know ..... Small Retailers like the Rakuten 11,000 only account for less than 0.5% of the purchasing power inside BURSA.
BURSA had always been Whales vs Big Sharks vs Small Sharks When I sit at Bangsar eating and drinking ,..... always overhear people losing RM10 million or losing 3 shop houses to those whales. Making profits inside BURSA is the exception and NOT the rule
Thats why I never bother begging people to buy any share coz it makes no difference at all. Whales will decide whether BPlant up or down....
I beg to differ. I think levy is imposed on the seller in indonesia.
e.g. Cap 1500USD, levy 25USD per tonne every dollar after.
for indonesian seller to make money, they hv to sell 1550USD. This way, seller and indonesian gov makes extra 25USD.
This is very smart. Last time indonesian DMO 30% price shoots up to the moon. Indonesian gov benefitted nothing. Without DMO but with levy, it will force the seller to sell higher if they plan to export and indonesian gov will benefit too. So, it becomes they either sell more expensive or sell less. Pick one.
Why so -ve? DMO removed, yes, international supply increase, BUT TOTAL WORLD demand n supply is same. YET additional levy will make Malaysia CPO more attractive…
RJ, levy is on sellers, I m not saying it’s against buyers, but naturally the levy will passed to buyers. Whn Khairuddin reintroduced export tax of 8%, remember? Price of CPO shoots up to cover the tax.
Whn Indon gov set DMO 30%, the intention is to increase supply with hope to control the price. Think this has failed coz price still go up. So they push the stocks to export n earn levy, use levy money to subsidise local price instead… yes it is smart as they are net exporter… but Malaysia being net exporter too yet they plan to review the subsidisation scheme…
Short term, I don’t know impact to Indon planters, but it’s for sure a positive to Malaysia planters… just hoped more stability to the policy as positive or negative, investors wants stability in terms of policy…
Whn the Indon CPO it’s USD1.5k, the max/cap levy is USD675 as compared to USD375 now… so the delta is the potential upside of Indo CPO, else their margin will erode
This defies logic. You set DMO, reduce global supply and expect price to come down?
Ok. We agree that levy is on the seller. Lets see if we can agree on this. "the levy will either force Indonesian to export at higher price to protect their margin or reduce export."
A true gentlemen will never shy away from rolling up his sleeves and get his hands dirty.
You have been courteous. I shall reciprocate the same. =D
"It is better to be violent, if there is violence in our hearts, than to put on the cloak of nonviolence to cover impotence." Try guess whose quote is this without googling. --------------------------------------------------------- brianklc
Btw, everyone can debate, but don’t call names like sinkalan or con or prostitute… healthy debates are productive…
Just do ur own studies on all info shared here n be aware that market might not be correlated to reality… if predictions can be so accurate, all will be right by 16 mar… just be careful to those only tell half of the story
Kindly note, at USD1.5k, levy of USD675 is 45%. If price stagnant at USD1.5k, they will rather sell domestically as their sales price is without levy. So, market forces will take place whn Indon planters prefer to sell domestically… my 2 cents
Scenario 1, Indon CPO don’t move, planters will sell more domestically as export levy takes up almost half of the sales price, they can bungkus. Less stock for export. Indo CPO price to increase.
This levy is more effective coz it lets market forces comes into play. Buyers can’t complain much coz Indon is protecting their interest. If they keep the DMO, buyers will curse them…
Indonesian DMO 30% where exporters need to prove 30% local sell before government give export permit is impractical to implement for the simple reason exporters already signed contracts with foreign buyer hence fail to deliver is contract default
To keep local CPO price low the government can just increase the levy so that the local CPO price is theoretical international price minus levy minus export duty.
RJ, DMO was meant to protect Indon ppl, with hope of price controlled whn domestic supply is more. Why Indon wanna care about foreign buyers? BUT, domestic price shoots up in line with export price, so DMO fails.
Corrections- Scenario 1, Indon CPO don’t move, planters will sell more domestically as export levy takes up almost half of the sales price, they can bungkus (if CPO price does not go up, better sell locally)… whn tht happen, less stock for export. Indo CPO price to increase.
Btw, on more extreme scenario… Sunflower oils reduction in coming months will cause shortage in supply, CPO price might increase further due to short supply… Indon domestic price will be up as well, guess what Indon gov will do? Will they subsidise more by increasing levy further? I don’t know…
The government has said it would use proceeds from levies to subsidise bulk cooking oil sales for the next six months, estimating about 202 million litres would bedistributed each month. The subsidy allocation was set at more than $500 million.”
This book is the result of the author's many years of experience and observation throughout his 26 years in the stockbroking industry. It was written for general public to learn to invest based on facts and not on fantasies or hearsay....
maestro85
248 posts
Posted by maestro85 > 2022-03-18 00:37 | Report Abuse
Bro tehcping this is big news
https://www.theedgemarkets.com/article/indonesia-takes-uturn-replace-palm-oil-export-curbs-levy
Indonesia buang limit quota utk export. rase harga akan jatuh lagi esok.