Posted by DividendGuy67 > 2 months ago | Report Abuse

I believe they should insist that Halal certification be provided free.
After all, why should the country protect the halal certifiers at the expense of the poor Malay retailers?
I totally support mandatory on the condition that it is given for free.
But if it's not free, then, why should the country protect only a few certifiers?
I rather protect the huge group of poor Malay retailers.

Posted by EngineeringProfit > 2 months ago | Report Abuse

At the expense of non-halal sectors? Malaysia’s heavy focus on promoting itself as a global halal hub, while beneficial in some ways, may divert attention and resources away from other sectors that have the potential for growth. For instance, non-halal industries, such as certain areas of technology, education, and tourism, may not receive the same level of support or investment, even though they could drive economic diversification and expansion. Neighboring countries with more balanced economic strategies can capitalize on these missed opportunities, leaving Malaysia behind.

Posted by speakup > 2 months ago | Report Abuse

when u make it mandatory, u give Jakim the power to decide which food biz flourish and which food biz go under. then this will open the door to corruption as some ppl will choose pay money to get halal cert

Posted by EngineeringProfit > 2 months ago | Report Abuse

Cash is king culture still here to live- alive and kicking?

Posted by Ravi1969 > 2 months ago | Report Abuse

Indonesia issues certs for free

Posted by Sslee > 2 months ago | Report Abuse

Nothing is free in this world as of afterworld no one come back to tell is every thing is free in the afterworld.

Posted by EngineeringProfit > 2 months ago | Report Abuse

Not based on come-back ppl telling- but from tradition, authority and revelation

Posted by cemertugus > 2 months ago | Report Abuse

just for information Halal Cert only RM100 a year or RM8.33 a month or RM0.27 per day.

Posted by EngineeringProfit > 2 months ago | Report Abuse

Do proper math. Tons of hidden cost and under the table money required - from the source to product prep. Procurement from limited source, etc. Think twice

Posted by EngineeringProfit > 2 months ago | Report Abuse

We must strive to put a full stop to such a dark system from the very begining. The strict criteria for halal certification affect not only food preparation but also the sourcing of raw materials. Businesses are required to use ingredients from halal-certified suppliers, limiting their options and increasing procurement costs. The scarcity of halal-certified suppliers in certain areas can further drive up the price of halal meals, as suppliers may charge a premium due to limited competition.

Posted by EngineeringProfit > 2 months ago | Report Abuse

And know why Kodak and Nokia became irrelevant - yup, dinosaur-like stagnation and morbidly unchanging. The rigid and overly cautious nature of JAKIM’s halal certification process may stifle innovation, particularly in industries that rely on fast-paced product development, such as food technology or pharmaceuticals. Entrepreneurs and investors may be deterred from developing innovative halal products or services due to fears of being bogged down in regulatory red tape. Malaysia risks missing out on becoming a leader in innovative halal markets, which are increasingly important in the global economy.

This stagnation in innovation can reduce the economy’s ability to diversify and grow, further shrinking the pie for all players. For example, Thailand’s emphasis on halal tourism, technology, and food production is becoming increasingly attractive to investors who seek lower barriers to entry.

Posted by EngineeringProfit > 2 months ago | Report Abuse

Mandatory halal certification introduces additional administrative and financial burdens, especially for small businesses. These include costs associated with compliance, auditing, and documentation, which can strain resources and reduce competitiveness, particularly for businesses that do not primarily cater to Muslim consumers. By enforcing certification, the government may inadvertently limit the flexibility and autonomy that businesses need to operate efficiently in a diverse market.

In contrast, a voluntary halal certification system would allow businesses to respond to market demand organically. Those that see value in obtaining halal certification—due to consumer preferences or market positioning—can do so without being forced. This market-driven approach encourages healthy competition and innovation, while avoiding the imposition of unnecessary costs on businesses that may not benefit from certification.

Forcing compliance could also create operational inefficiencies, leading to higher prices for consumers and reducing the overall agility of businesses in adapting to changing market conditions. Thus, voluntary certification strikes a balance, supporting both the needs of relevant consumers and the sustainability of diverse business operations.

Posted by EngineeringProfit > 2 months ago | Report Abuse

After all, great minds and people discuss great ideas, small minded, hearted and pen*le ppl attack the former ones

Posted by cemertugus > 2 months ago | Report Abuse

I'm just answer to those said the Halal Cert is expensive, JAKIM only chargers few hundred. I'm not sure cost for consultation fee and other hidden cost. They only purpose mandatory for Halal cert maybe because current issue big F&B don't have halal cert but most of their customer are Muslim. i don't think they can make compulsory to all. We have cabinet member to discuss and make discussion regarding this issue.

Posted by Sslee > 2 months ago | Report Abuse

It is not the certificate cost per se but the cost on inplementation added up in all the supply chain.

Posted by cemertugus > 2 months ago | Report Abuse

i agreed with @EngineeringProfit, "Those that see value in obtaining halal certification—due to consumer preferences or market positioning" maybe can go for Halal Cert. they can voluntarily apply for Halal Cert. If their market for Non-Muslim, no required to have Halal Cert.

Posted by EngineeringProfit > 2 months ago | Report Abuse

And depend on use of technology like the case of Cadbury chocolate in 2016. And soon advanced testing for presence of alcohol - abusing technology is never cheap for the general people to pay. Hard time now . Many B40. Just need food. Affordable price- not inflated one

Posted by qqq47660 > 2 months ago | Report Abuse

Malaysia 3R hurdles and traps.

Posted by qqq47660 > 2 months ago | Report Abuse

of course she is right, but thats why makes her so dangerous.

Posted by EngineeringProfit > 2 months ago | Report Abuse

Yes, democracy (government by the ppl, of the ppl for the ppl) means every single rakyat must stand up against injustice, cruelty and kezaliman. Let the business ppl decide for themselves.

Posted by cemertugus > 7 hours ago | Report Abuse

i agreed with @EngineeringProfit, "Those that see value in obtaining halal certification—due to consumer preferences or market positioning" maybe can go for Halal Cert. they can voluntarily apply for Halal Cert. If their market for Non-Muslim, no required to have Halal Cert.

Posted by DividendGuy67 > 1 month ago | Report Abuse

F&B operators are either halal or non halal. Mandatory halal certification for Muslim F&B traders - if given free - doesn’t come at anyone else expense except for those who certify. If a Muslim trader choose to sell non halal F&B, I think many will have serious problems with that. So I see no problem to make it mandatory to Muslim F&B operators only if the certification is given for FREE and doesn’t disturb the Muslim traders. There is no “At the expense of others”.

Posted by DividendGuy67 > 1 month ago | Report Abuse

However if it is NOT FREE, then I seriously object. They must make the certification FREE and FAST. Then when every Muslim F&B trader have it, nobody gives a damn anymore. Case closed!

Posted by DividendGuy67 > 1 month ago | Report Abuse

If you are a Muslim, you must support mandatory halal certification for FREE and FAST. If you are a non Muslim, you must also support mandatory halal certification for FREE and FAST. A Muslim trader MUST take a stand and take a position whether he wants to be a Muslim F&B trader or not. If he doesn’t want, I don’t think anyone will allow him to sell pork and alcohol. Since he can’t sell pork and alcohol just give him that halal certification FREE and FAST and the country can move on to do bigger and better things.

Posted by DividendGuy67 > 1 month ago | Report Abuse

But don’t make it SLOW and COSTLY! The poor Muslim F&B trader won’t survive!

Posted by DividendGuy67 > 1 month ago | Report Abuse

When it is given FREE and FAST, you do not give JAKIM more power on F&B. When EVERYONE have it, it ceases to be of value.

Posted by DividendGuy67 > 1 month ago | Report Abuse

So, 23 days to certify is 22 days too long. One day max. In the spot. FREE!

Posted by DividendGuy67 > 1 month ago | Report Abuse

I totally agree with the use of the most advanced technology. Digital certificates can be issued in less than 1 second. Issue them! To everyone!

Posted by speakup > 1 month ago | Report Abuse

yawn! PH sama mcm zaman BN je. no difference

Posted by speakup > 1 month ago | Report Abuse

baca ni: http://www.financetwitter.com/2024/09/forcing-halal-certification-jakim-wants-to-play-god-pm-anwar-wants-dap-to-bend-over-like-mca.html

Posted by EngineeringProfit > 1 month ago | Report Abuse

With the commoners in her heart, Nyonya Teresa can be a better pm than AI

Posted by EngineeringProfit > 1 month ago | Report Abuse

For Malsia, the lessons are clear: without decisive reforms to remove parasitic middlemen, inefficient agencies, and entrenched interests, the nation risks economic stagnation, social discontent, and a loss of competitiveness in the global economy. Ancient civilizations serve as a stark reminder that ignoring these issues can lead to unsalvageable decline.

Posted by qqq47660 > 1 month ago | Report Abuse

Malaysia 3R hurdles and traps.

we just have to improve our handling 3 R issues...that includes all sides.

Thailand seems to have handled it better .

Posted by EngineeringProfit > 1 month ago | Report Abuse

How?..............By playing their related issues down or up?

Posted by qqq47660 > 1 month ago | Report Abuse

Chinese kids have 3 R meaning reading, writing and arithmetic.
malaysian adults have 3R issues meaning race, religion and royalty.

Posted by qqq47660 > 1 month ago | Report Abuse

Thailand seems to have handled it better .

Thailand handles it expertly with no one winning everything

thailand is so good, the country was never colonised. and now thailand is a favorite for investors.

Posted by qqq47660 > 1 month ago | Report Abuse

Thailand has democraccy with Thai characteristics.

Malaysia must reach a level of democarcy with Malaysia characteristics, not all white house or westminster uk or western characteristics only.

Posted by EngineeringProfit > 1 month ago | Report Abuse

Unfortunately, 3R in the context of the 21st-century Industrial Revolution 4.0 that everyone should learn, internalise and master are:

Resilient: Emphasizes the need for systems and businesses to be adaptable and robust in the face of rapid technological changes and disruptions.

Responsive: Highlights the importance of agility and quick adaptation to emerging trends, technologies, and market demands.

Revolutionary: Reflects the transformative impact of Industry 4.0 technologies, driving innovation and significant changes in industry practices and processes.

How ill-prepared could we be?

Posted by qqq47660 > 5 minutes ago | Report Abuse

Thailand seems to have handled it better .

Thailand handles it expertly with no one winning everything

thailand is so good, the country was never colonised. and now thailand is a favorite for investors.

Posted by qqq47660 > 1 month ago | Report Abuse

what the malays complain about is that the girl is just too china girl look and feel.

Posted by qqq47660 > 1 month ago | Report Abuse

politics cannot be handled with just the frontal cortex or logical deductions.
politics in a country with 3 R issues have be handled together with the emotional brain.

that is no such thing as successful leader, successful social media, successful commentator unless it comes equipped with EI. emotional intelligence.

Posted by qqq47660 > 1 month ago | Report Abuse

that is no such thing as successful leader, successful social media, successful commentator unless it comes equipped with EI. emotional intelligence.

or what they CCP says harmony.

Posted by EngineeringProfit > 1 month ago | Report Abuse

We got no time for that- don't u see the country debt would become unbearable soon. Still have to hold on to all the dinosaur policies, principles and practices by all the dinosaur agencies?

Posted by EngineeringProfit > 1 month ago | Report Abuse

Malsia must do the only one right thing i.e. streamline all eateries to be 1msian-friendly- streamline its regulatory functions, allowing for more direct business operations without the need for religious bodies like JKIM to have such a prominent role in commercial and certification processes. This could lead to a less politicized, more economically progressive environment that favors transparency and direct governance.

Posted by EngineeringProfit > 1 month ago | Report Abuse

While the religious bodies play a significant role in cultural and spiritual matters, the allocation of public funds to these agencies is often questioned, especially in times of economic stress. Some argue that focusing on providing basic needs like education, healthcare, housing, and infrastructure would have a more direct and measurable impact on national prosperity than maintaining extensive religious bureaucracies.