Those shareholders remained are those who knew the real values of PJ Dev. That includes one Big Five accounting firm ex-partner. As the previous offer was extremely unreasonable, those who knew the real worth rejected the offer. Based on the present poor market condition, Tan Sri may find difficulties to place out shares to meet the requirement. His another option is to make another low offer. I think the remaining shareholders will not accept and may reject another low offer again.
Tan sri is one of those boss, you don't want to work with. There are good fundumental company and bad company. But good fundemtal company with bad boss that don't care about the shareholders are also bad company.
Based on the list of the Group's Top Ten Properties, almost all the properties in the book are not revalued and undervalued.
For example, the land in You City, the 10.71ac land is the most valuable in that area. The proposed future development will be directly facing the highway and directly connected to MRT1 which will be operational in 2017. On 5/7/2016, Guocoland bought from market the land which is exactly behind this piece of land at RM248/ sq ft. I think the You City land should reasonably worth RM350/sq. ft. as compared to RM60/sq ft in the book. The Revised Net Book Value should be RM163.3mil as compared to RM28.2mil in the book. There is a undervaluation of RM135.1mil just for this piece of land.
The link for recent transaction of the land behind PJ Development by Guocoland.
Don't sell. The offers are worse than the previous offers. We should not be bullied by this ridiculous take-over deal which is UNFAIR & UNREASONABLE.
Bear in mind that OSKH is DESPERATE in taking PJD private.
We together can actually hold this unfair and unreasonable plan to our advantage by NOT SELLING. We can then demand a more reasonable price together considering that there are much more values in PJD than reported.
As discussed by others, the almost all land are undervalued. The multi-billion Melbourne project alone is going to bring in huge profits, which the ongs what to take for themselves and not to share with us.
Offer price for Warrants is more ridiculous, since there is over 4 years maturity date.
I shall write to MSWG (Minority shareholders Watchdog Group) to request for a forum of minority shareholders of PJDEV. We need to group together to demand a fair & reasonable offer - NOT worse and worse offer.
Just wondering, maybe those that are familiar with all the regulations can explain, is there any chance where they can force the remaining minority share holder to sell their share if they public spread has reach a certain percentage?
Yeah better be clear with the terms and condition. I know some of the guys here ask to hold and refuse to sell. Just don't want some to run into the stage where the shareholders have no choice but to force sell to them with a much lower price after that
FAIRnREASONABLE, you are right. The Melbourne Southbank is jewel of the crown of PJ Development. The first phase of the project will be launched in end of this year.
Please write to Mr Quah Ban Aik, the Head of Corporate Monitoring & Investor Complaints of MSWG (Minority Shareholder Watchdog Group) to ask MSWG to organise a forum for minority shareholders of PJD. When sufficient number write in, the forum will be organised.
His email is: banaik.quah@mswg.org.my
MSWG organized such a forum in 2014 and published its computation of PJD warrant at a value of 1.57 against offer at 0.60.
We were misled by directors of PJD & OSKH who had all along stated openly the desire to maintain the listed status of PJD. Many believed that and invested (not trading) for the long-term in PJD.
Better avoid ong pig pig company,he the same like politician ,the word out from his mouth can't even believe...in his mind only wanna to "eat"and "rob"....fxxxxxxxx
This book is the result of the author's many years of experience and observation throughout his 26 years in the stockbroking industry. It was written for general public to learn to invest based on facts and not on fantasies or hearsay....
Wahlaueh
208 posts
Posted by Wahlaueh > 2016-06-11 20:46 | Report Abuse
Tan Sri might ask for another 6 months extension...