Patience required.... According to Focus Malaysia, their old (high cost) inventories would be fully used up in the March quarter. Next quarter will reflect better margin
1Q hit by forex losses Thong Guan’s 1QFY15 net profit, at 53% annualised, was below market and our expectations as its earnings was hit by realised forex losses and also lower revenue contribution from Japan, its largest market. We cut our FY15-17 EPS forecasts to reflect slower sales from Japan and forex losses. Our target price also falls based on unchanged 30% discount to its fully-diluted SOP. Potential re-rating catalysts are EBITDA margin recovery and sales recovery from Japan market. The stock remains an Add. 1Q15 net profit down due to realised forex loss Although Thong Guan’s 1Q15 revenue was only down 9.6% yoy, its 1Q15 net profit was down 45% yoy, mainly due to forex losses – RM3.4m realised and RM0.8m unrealised. The lower revenue was mainly due to lower average selling prices (due to the fall in crude oil prices) and softer sales from Japan. No interim dividend was declared, in line with our expectations. Excluding the realised and unrealised forex losses, Thong Guan’s 1Q15 EBITDA margin was 7.0%, just slightly lower than 1Q14’s 7.1%. It is impressive that the company can sustain its EBITDA margin in 1Q15 on the back of lower revenue. We believe this was possible as the weaker Ringgit helped, in terms of lowering labour and electricity costs as most of its revenue was denominated in US$. Weaker Japan sales Sales from its biggest market, Japan (accounts for ~30% of revenue), declined in 1Q15, mainly due to slower demand starting from Apr as sales tax increased from 5% to 8%. By Oct 2015, sales tax will rise to 10%. We understand that higher sales taxes were needed in Japan to cover the rising social welfare costs for its aging population. This country has one of the world’s lowest birth rates and the world's highest ratio of elderly to young people. This raised concerns about its long-term economic growth. Debt-free balance sheet Thong Guan’s balance sheet featured RM2m net cash as at end-Mar. There were no major capex in 1Q15. Its capex was RM28.9m in 2014 and RM15.4m in 2013. We estimate that the company will invest RM100m in total over 2014-2016 to raise its annual production capacity from 120,000 tonnes to 170,000 tonnes, main focus on thin stretch films and PVC food wrap films.
Hi, cbt. totally agree wiht Icon8888. Don't too much worry because Tguan earning just affect by Marco factor which is temporary.I foresee a knee jack result after those marco factor.
Actually fluctuation of oil price is not much affect the earning because packaging product are almost trade as commodity. Raw material cost will converse to selling price because of competitive market. But the sharp drop ( -20 to -50 % in short term ) of oil price and RM currency is an occasional case. this may diff because,
1. Last quarter inventory average cost is higher than profit margin.
2. Tgaun secure most of the borrowing in USD. Weaken RM dilute earning in overall.
Do you know why earning per share drop? When need money to buy new equipment, report show very good up trend. Because need share holder to support. Now no need already, sure show down trend. Bcos later they propose share buyback. This shows big fish eat small fish.
their operation is 75% export and benefits from low Ringgit
However, they have some forex exposure
Some are loans, some are payables booked in on quarterly basis.
When currency moves from one level to a lower level, the previous quarter payables will get hit
Their underlying profit is strong, just distorted by forex losses. Optimum scenario is when currency stabilize, and remains low. That is when they stopped making losses on quarterly payables and yet enjoy fat margin
Not exactly a dead case yet. I did a quick calculation, the net effect should still be positive (in fact, very positive). The more the RM depreciates, the stronger the operating profit, and it is more than sufficient to offset the forex loss.
Last quarter the weak RM boasted net profit to RM8 mil, but forex losses was RM4 mil. However, if the bulk of the forex loan losses had been provided and what was left was forex payables, next quarter forex loss could be lessen (hopefully)
However, no point for me to defense them, have to wait for coming quarter result.
Post a Comment
People who like this
New Topic
You should check in on some of those fields below.
Title
Category
Comment
Confirmation
Click Confirm to delete this Forum Thread and all the associated comments.
This book is the result of the author's many years of experience and observation throughout his 26 years in the stockbroking industry. It was written for general public to learn to invest based on facts and not on fantasies or hearsay....
Icon8888
18,659 posts
Posted by Icon8888 > 2015-05-27 12:25 | Report Abuse
Not yet, but set aside some bullets