Keeping 11.57% and being a passive investor in E&O is meaningless to Sime Property. Sime Property has to either sell the shareholdings away or increase its stakes. Sime Property bought the shares about 5 years ago at RM2.30 a share. It means Sime Property will be making losses if they sell them away at the current price. They also risk being looked foolish when the share price climb to a much higher level in the next few years.
Why Sime Property had bought into E&O at RM2.30 a share in 2013 in the first place? They must have hired professionals to calculate, performed due diligence and found out that it worth more than RM2.30 a share. I think Sime Property should take advantage of the current low price level to increase its stakes or talk to Lembaga Tabung Haji if they intend to sell its stakes. Lembaga Tabung Haji was seen reducing its shareholdings in the open market recently.
@dusti, the statutory funds like EPF, Lembaga Tabung Haji and KWAP are taking quite significant positions in E&O. Among the three, KWAP has taking even more aggressive stance by participating directly into the developments of STP2. The first project that is scheduled to be launched in the next 6 to 9 months in STP2 will be a JV between KWAP and E&O.
More than 10 years ago, companies are allowed and encouraged to revalue their landbanks. Therefore, the NTA would reflect the actual market values of the landbanks. However, the subsequent FRS (Financial Reporting Standards) by Bursa requires the landbanks to be carried at cost. This new requirements is suitable for companies who bought lands for immediate developments like SDB, Hua Yang, MCT, Thriven and Sunsuria.
However, there are some companies that bought their development landbanks and keep them for a long time, between 10 years to as long as 40 years in some cases. The NTA in this type of companies is grossly underestimated. As the NTA does not show the true picture of the company, the financial analysts then create a new term for the actual NTA when the current market values of the properties are calculated. They name it RNAV (Revised Net Asset Values). In fact, the RNAV is actually the NTA of the development companies.
I would say Bursa has set the wrong FRS and enable the property counters to grossly underestimate their NTAs and hence artificially suppress the share price of the property counters. The major shareholders are very happy with this because they can buy back the shares from the market either in their personal capacities or company share buybacks at very low price. That is the reason that there were so many privatisations taken place in these few years in property counters.
This includes Hunza, OSK Property, PJ Dev, Wing Tai and a few more. The two ongoing mandatory general offers are TA and TAGB. The major shareholders are taking advantage of the wrong situations and ignorant of the general retail shareholders. If Bursa Malaysia does not revise the FRS and corrects the situations, more and more companies will be privatised. The counters that fall into this catogery are E&O, MKH, Paramount, Oriental, TA, TAGB, KSL, Tropicana and some others.
Many of the retail investors do not have the financial knowledge and are fooled by the wrong situations. For me, I am equipped with the financial knowledge and many years of experience in Bursa to witness and realise the wrong development took place.
hi enid888 , by your reckoning (as insider?) E &O should be zooming towards 2.30 + for Sime to break even or better . Was hoping for management to make some bullish announcements soon.......but....................
Generally, STP2A has been completely reclaimed and all the land titles have been issued. E&O sold 6 plots of land (bulk sales) to the Tier 1 pioneer investor KWAP at discounted prices (about RM500 to RM550 per sq.ft) about 2 years ago. That land sale was carried out to bring in cash to finance the ongoing reclamation work then. With the land plots can be physically witnessed now, E&O targets to sell some of the remaining plots to potential building owners or developers at the prevailing market price which I think should be between RM700 to RM900 per sq.ft). Preference will be given to potential buyers who intend to develop the land fast and preferably with iconic buildings.
Major shareholder offers to buy at RM3.00 a share. Last trading price was RM2.17 per share. The offer is 38.2% higher than the last trading price. This is the proof that property counters are trading at "lelong" price just like E&O.
I am not asking you to buy. If you buy at 1.31 and below, surely you are unlikely to lose money.
I will not tell you to buy only after E&O already move up by 20%. That is not noble, and not doing thing in good faith. You should know whom I am referring to.........
This counter has been on its down trend since August and wonder whether it has reached its bottom? Bearing in mind its asset mainly around Penang. Your opinion pls.
This book is the result of the author's many years of experience and observation throughout his 26 years in the stockbroking industry. It was written for general public to learn to invest based on facts and not on fantasies or hearsay....
enid888
581 posts
Posted by enid888 > 2018-06-14 13:21 | Report Abuse
Keeping 11.57% and being a passive investor in E&O is meaningless to Sime Property. Sime Property has to either sell the shareholdings away or increase its stakes. Sime Property bought the shares about 5 years ago at RM2.30 a share. It means Sime Property will be making losses if they sell them away at the current price. They also risk being looked foolish when the share price climb to a much higher level in the next few years.
Why Sime Property had bought into E&O at RM2.30 a share in 2013 in the first place? They must have hired professionals to calculate, performed due diligence and found out that it worth more than RM2.30 a share. I think Sime Property should take advantage of the current low price level to increase its stakes or talk to Lembaga Tabung Haji if they intend to sell its stakes. Lembaga Tabung Haji was seen reducing its shareholdings in the open market recently.