I also believe PJD would be the acquirer. PJD always say they target to become top 5 developer of the country. It also make sense that PJD acquire OSKProp as OLH seems having more direct holding in OSKP. If the deal is shareswap + cash, OLH can cash out & increase his holding % in PJD too.
I suspect Osk will acquire the merged entity in the end. Just like the rhb-cimb-mbsb hook-up. Mr. OLH may borrow the idea from Mr. Nazir. Stay put for the second wave. no need to hurry, still got wayang to see.
Any counters related to him I will never touched. He is such a stingy businessman. Dont expect anything good from him. Period. OSK PROPERTY RM2, PJDEV RM1.60. Now you know why PJdev drops like hell today
i beg to differ. OLH is the shrewdest stockbroker i ever dealt with. i have many dealing with him in the 90s. when osk was just a medium size broker. he handled n involved in all major deals hands on. i have made it a point not to touch anything OLH/OSK since.
Today, OSK launched take over offers for OSK Property and PJ Development principally via issuance of new OSK shares.
After studying the proposals, it suddenly dawned on me that Ong Leung Huat is the biggest loser of the scheme (and he apparently is not aware of that)
I believed the scheme was cooked up in a haste without giving proper thoughts on the actual implication on Ong Leung Huat's financial interest (Probably as a knee jerk reaction to recent market downturn which they thought provides a window of opportunity to create a smart deal to benefit Ong Leung Huat)
Whoever that conceptualize the deal should be fired by Ong Leung Huat. The old man has been badly advised.
I am ready to back up my argument with facts and figures. Unfortunately I have an early flight to catch tomorrow. So you all need to wait for probably another day before I come up with a proper write up.
in the 90s, so many brokers r bigger than osk. but OLH has the forsight to paid former bursa chairman to be osk chairman. and push for branches and Investment banks license and get to where he is today.
what happen to TA? and all others much bigger one? they were acquired.
i had many deals with him and he pick up call immedietely and always in office monitoring stock prices.
Go to OSKH counter to check how OLH repeated his old trick to PJPROPERTY & PJDEV, same kind of story - offer peanuts, not delisting, later, price will go up. So, dont be stupid.
hello good day everyone ! As a newcomer to the Blog ,may i give little view of my own,if Oskprop is still listing on the board,the changing of hand between the "Two" at this stupid price is really none of our business, as long as our small shareholders with exceeding 20% don't give way.they cant do anything about it.And all this while we know very well that Oskprop is making a good profit and is reaching $3/= in near future.If Ong wanted to sell at Zero price is so ok for him,because is a changing of hand from right to left only, and somemore he can get control of Osk Holding.
so our small shareholders please don't jump into the trap.the volume done today and the sharp fall in this short period , how do u know is not a cruel play by the big shark! please stay calm and DONT sell your share.!!
This old fox is so cunning so that during this critical moment announced this "news". so the small shareholders will sell all their shares to him.Below market value !! What to talk about 1.5X book value ?? omg. how come he got no mercy on us ,the small shareholders which follow him so far?
I did some analysis n found that OLH is on the losing side in this deal just like u n me. Atria with net lettable area of 500,000 sq ft will be opened within these 2 months and it is worth more than RM550mil (comparatively, Tropicana City's valuation is RM1,100 per sq ft). That works out to be about RM2.25/share just for Atria alone. Other revised net value that reflects the current values of development land like Cyberjaya, Sungai Petani, Shah Alam including other assets and liabilities are valued at about RM3.00/share. Therefore, the actual Revised Net Value of OSKP is worth RM5.25/share.
On the other hand, the land and properties of OSK Holdings had just been revalued in Dec 12 or Dec 13 which means the net book values has already reflected the present values. Taking into consideration of its holdings in RHB Capital, the revised net value of OSKH is abt RM2.65/share.
By this calculation, each share of OSKP is worth 2 shares of OSKH. It should be each OSKP share is exchanged with 2 shares of OSKH.
OLH holds 73% of OSKP, therefore it should benefits him more if the share swap is done based on the actual revised book values of both companies.
Icon8888, good to know that we hv the same views. However, how do u think the situation will develop? For example, if the minority shareholders (say 15% or 20% total shareholdings) did not take up the offer. What will OLH do?
Icon888, agreed with u. But in the situation that he is unable to get 90% or more, the delisting may not happened. However, how is OSKP going to comply to 25% shareholding spread requirement?
I agree with ww123 and icon8888, hold tight tight, OSKProp & PJDev are highly undervalued based on its fundamentals. It's not a fair deal by the oldfox to minority shareholders, expect a better proposal soon...
It is suprised that Focus Malaysia didn't cover the OSK, Oskprop, and PJDev merger. Starbiz onky cover in the small commentary part. And I havent check The Edge Weekly. Unlike when Sime darby launch takeover for NBPOL from Kulim. Analyst rushed to give their yes/no opinion to the takeover offer, the next day after announcement! Even Starbiz and Focus Mlysia still cover this Sime darby story. But I believe that generally any analyst wouldnt agree with the Osk offer, and maybe OLH to powerful that no analyst dare to discredit him
As I wrote earlier, PJdev deal wont go through, in condition that allied party to OLH cant fully acquire pjdev. You can see how Pjdev share price is suppresed yesterday to clear out contra players, panicked and uninformed investors and to create illusion that pjdev takeover will definitely occur. It will takewa long way since pjdev is bigger and they need another 58% to force a full takeover. it is not easy!
for oskprop, it is an obviously easy target but it depend if they can get 90% acceptance. investors should not sell now and should ask for better price instead.
I believe that apart from the stingy old man OLH, OSK does not have financial muscle to fund the takeover through cash since all the money is in form of Rhb stake. They only receive dividends and their lending money business is not substantial. that is why they also offer shares. and OLH dnesnt want to burden his OSK with debt, since his aspiration is to ultimately control OSK tight in his grab. If you read carefully, the 15 cent dividend and warrant is for current shareholders, meaning the effective takeover price is RM1.85 (or less since warrant will increase on day of listing) not RM2.00/OSK shares. That showp how cunning's OLH is.
If OLH share swap his OSKP @ RM2.00 as well. I think he will not let OSKH trading @ RM2.00. Potential for OSKH to surge 40%-50% from RM2.0 after deal. (OSKP minority shareholder will get rewarded too from OSKH share price. Anyhow, same entry price with OLH mah)
hi dear all, i am also burned with holding pjd and pjd warrants. Just starting to buy OSKH, should i sell off all my PJD-WC since there will be no egm for us to reject his proposal? Anyone can explain what is the process now since i understand there is no need of egm as this is a "willing buyer willing seller" and not > 33% by this cunning OLH?
hi azlan, once OSKH they sell rhb stake for cash, then we all fatt fatt instead of have to worry - reason is they must offer you a "good" price if not how to acquire all of pjdev ? It's always the acquiring company must pay a good price in order to acquire another company.
a victim has complained to Security Commission & cc to Minority Watchdog Group on the following events:
Event 1. On 10th Oct 2014 –appear in Star Online: PJD-OSK Property merger ‘quite soon’, no privatisation of merged company http://www.thestar.com.my/Business/Business-News/2014/10/10/PJDOSK-Property-merger-quite-soon-Ong-No-intention-to-privatise-merged-company/?style=biz The contents of the news: KUALA LUMPUR: A merger and consolidation exercise between PJ Development Bhd (PJD) and OSK Property Holdings Bhd is expected to materialise soon. Veteran stockbroker TSOLH said the exercise “will be quite soon”…. ….Meanwhile, he expects PJD’s net profit to grow by 20% for the financial year ending June 30, 2015. “This will be backed by the advancement of certain projects, with the majority of it coming from YOU City @ Cheras, among others,” he said. …..Yesterday, PJD received unanimous shareholder approval to purchase about 2ha of freehold land in Melbourne, Australia for RM432.1mil, equivalent to RM21,307 per sq m
Question No. 1: Is the news and announcement misleading to the public? Now is not merger but tri-party private agreement. And announcement of merger and 20% grow, does it give false confident to the market? Market response on 10th Oct 2014: PJD CLOSE + 1CENTS UP AT 1.80, OSK PROP + 10 CENTS UP AT 2.45, but FBMKLCI down -21 POINTS & most counters down. Has the major shareholder declared the oncoming private tri-party Share Sale Agreement (SSA) before the AGM voting on the purchase of land in Australia, the outcome could have been different. The SSA was announced on 15th Oct 2014 and it is not ink over night.
Event 2. On 14th Oct 2014, 6.32pm, BURSA web announcement: Changes in Director's Interest (S135) - Ong Ju Xing http://www.bursamalaysia.com/market/listed-companies/company-announcements/1765141 The Director is believed to be closely related to the major shareholder. Further study note that the changes is by his spouse purchase made in year 2013.
Question No. 2: Why the Director made announcement for purchase made in 2013? Does it give false market confident again if one did not study in detail of the purchase?
Event 3. On 15th Oct 2014, 7.22pm announcement of Multiple Proposal as per the subject of this letter. The market response with the counter OSK property & PJD gap down.
Question No.3: Does this proposal contradict what is being said on 10th Oct 2014,as it is different takeover offer : mandatory take-over for OSK Property but voluntary take over for PJ Development.
SC is to scrutinise the events and whether the proposal is in breach of any regulation, and check who are the buyers and sellers before and after the events.The action of the major shareholder has disrupted free market mechanism and able to manipulate market price...and able to outsmart the minority share holders at his mercy with paper shuffling,. .... dangerous precedent will be made by major shareholder of this modus operandi in future by depressing market prices to his advantage,... even if the security counter has good fundamental. & what will happen to the market if the major shareholder aborts his SSA abruptly?......
*********************************************************************************************************************** "Victims " are strongly encourage to write to the authority on the unfair action etc.. at your own extra points...
For the benefits of those miss the details( TQ to Mr Ravi Kumar and many others help to compile the contact)
Investor Affairs & Complaints Department Securities Commission Malaysia No 3 Persiaran Bukit Kiara Bukit Kiara 50490 Kuala Lumpur Tel: 603 6204 8999 Fax: 603 6204 8991 E-mail: aduan@seccom.com.my & CC to Lya Rahman General Manager, Corporate Services MINORITY SHAREHOLDER WATCHDOG GROUP (MSWG) 11th Floor EPF Building Changkat Raja Chulan Off Jalan Raja Chulan 52000 KUALA LUMPUR Tel: (603) 2070 9090 Fax: (603) 2070 9107 & btw MSWG would be organising a forum where the issues can be discussed. The event will be held as follows:
Date: 5 November 2014 Time: 2.00 pm Venue: MSWG Training Centre, Minority Shareholder Watchdog Group 11th Floor, Bangunan KWSP, No. 3, Changkat Raja Chulan\ Off Jalan Raja Chulan, 50200 Kuala Lumpur 2 pm registration 2.30 to 3.45 pm PJDEV and OSKP (Takeover)
Contact the following to register via phone or email Ms.Zairina zairina@mswg.org.my Mr.Vinodth vinodth.ram@mswg.org.my Ms.Sharon sharongoh@mswg.org.my
Time to make your voice heard. Good luck.!!
***************************************************************************************************** "The Only Thing Necessary for the Triumph of Evil is that Good Men Do Nothing "-Edmund Burke *****************************************************************************************************
This book is the result of the author's many years of experience and observation throughout his 26 years in the stockbroking industry. It was written for general public to learn to invest based on facts and not on fantasies or hearsay....
azlan88
509 posts
Posted by azlan88 > 2014-10-09 20:26 | Report Abuse
btw, hopefully OSKProp announce windfall dividends too before merging. =)